More people are buying crossovers than any other type of vehicle, and that means automakers are rushing to churn out new models and snatch up a larger share of the market. What makes the best crossovers so irresistible? Not every buyer is looking for the same thing, but among their more attractive characteristics, crossovers provide greater visibility, utility, and styling diversity than modern sedans — which used to wear the sales crown. Unlike SUVs, crossovers also ride on lightweight car-based platforms, meaning fuel economy is nearly as good as sedans.
Tremendous competition makes the task of sifting through these crossover options that much harder. Fortunately, we’re here to return your sanity. This year, we’ve tested subcompact, compact, midsize, and luxury crossover models from every major brand. Several of these vehicles impressed us, but only a handful of them blew us away. Here are our top picks.
At a glance
|Jaguar F-Pace||The best||Not yet rated|
|Subaru Ascent||The best midsize crossover||Not yet rated|
|Volvo XC40||The best compact crossover||Not yet rated|
|Volvo XC90||The best luxury crossover||Not yet rated|
|Jeep Renegade||The best subcompact crossover||4 out of 5|
|Porsche Macan Turbo||The best performance crossover||Not yet rated|
|MINI Countryman S E ALL4||The most fuel-efficient crossover||3.5 out of 5|
Why should you buy this: It drives even better than it looks.
Who’s it for? Luxury buyers who are tired of the same German car options.
How much will it cost? $44,600
Why we picked the Jaguar F-Pace:
It’s not difficult to find a beautiful sports car, motorcycle, or premium sedan, but asking for a gorgeous crossover is a tall order. Despite the swollen number of options, crossovers tend not to look nearly as sleek as lower riding vehicles. However, Jaguar’s head of design, Ian Callum, was apparently up to the challenge when he molded the F-Pace.
The F-Pace certainly isn’t first to market – in fact, the luxury crossover segment was fairly stacked before the UK automaker introduced their crossover in 2016. However, most will forgive the wait upon seeing the car’s curvaceous bodywork. Inspired by the F-Type’s stunning physique, the F-Pace manages to look even more upscale than its German luxury rivals. Better yet, it performs like the agile cat after which it is named.
Powering the F-Pace is a variety of turbocharged and supercharged engines. The base 25t gets a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder producing 247 horsepower. Next up is the 20d, which sports a 180-hp 2.0-liter turbodiesel four, followed by the 30t, which uses a 296-hp version of the gasoline turbo four. The F-Pace S gets a 3.0-liter supercharged V6 making 380 hp. For 2019, Jag is also adding a sporty SVR version, boasting a 550-hp 5.0-liter supercharged V8. All models utilize a ZF eight-speed automatic and are available with all-wheel drive.
Inside, the Jag features a wonderfully comfortable cabin. Rich leather, ergonomic seats, and an intuitive 10.2-inch infotainment system are just some of the highlights. In short, the F-Pace checks every box on the crossover list, and even creates a few new ones to keep the competition at bay.
The best midsize crossover
Why should you buy this: It’s a big vehicle that doesn’t feel big.
1 sentence description of why product is good (for product card): The Ascent takes everything good about smaller Subarus and blows it up to family-size proportions.
Who’s it for: Large families.
How much will it cost: $31,995+
Why we picked the Subaru Ascent:
The Ascent was designed primarily to keep Subaru owners who needed bigger vehicles from defecting to other brands, but it’s a solid choice even if your current ride isn’t a Forester or Outback. In addition to plenty of space (including a headline-grabbing 19 cupholders), the seven-seat Ascent boasts a solid array of tech features and impressive driving dynamics.
Available tech features include built-in Wi-Fi that can support up to eight devices, and a rearview mirror that displays streaming video. Similar to versions offered on certain General Motors and Nissan vehicles, it displays a feed from a rear-mounted camera in the mirror, giving the driver a view unobstructed by rear pillars or passengers’ heads. The Ascent is also available with Subaru’s EyeSight bundle of driver-assist features, which includes adaptive cruise control, autonomous emergency braking, and lane-keep assist, as well as a head-up display that shows safety warnings.
While not a sports car, the Ascent is also quite nice to drive. The 2.4-liter turbocharged boxer-four engine’s 260 hp and 277 lb-ft are more than adequate and, unlike some competitors, Subaru offers all-wheel drive as standard equipment. The Ascent handles twisty back roads like a much smaller car, and even offers a useful 5,000 pounds of towing capacity.
The best compact crossover
Why should you buy this: Contemporary European practicality, European styling, user-friendliness.
Who’s it for? Those who want the nicest and easiest compact crossover.
How much will it cost? $33,200
Why we picked the Volvo XC40:
Sitting at the top of the Best Compact Crossover category is the all-new 2018 Volvo XC40, which we briefly drove not too long ago. We love the Volvo’s ability to charm not just its occupants, but all those seeing you pull up at your destination. The XC40’s purely contemporary and elegant European design is easy on the eyes, yet very 21st-century. And the human-centric and driver-friendly interior makes time spent traveling in the XC40 less of a chore.
It’s certainly geared more toward comfort than sport and performance. But while it may not be as much of a thrill as the BMW X1, its refinement and smooth ride check all the boxes for a competent near-luxury crossover.
With the XC40, Volvo also seeks to break the traditional “three-year lease” ownership cycle for a subscription service to use their vehicles. Depending on location, the XC40 also comes with Care by Volvo. It’s access to a bespoke range of digital concierge services such as refueling, cleaning, service pick-up and drop-off, and more, all with hopes to minimize the traditional hassles that come with opening and operating a vehicle.
Our full 2019 Volvo XC40 first-drive review
The best luxury crossover
Why should you buy this: Volvo’s XC90 defines the word “elegance.”
Who’s it for? Long-time German luxury buyers who want an upgrade.
How much will it cost? $46,900
Why we picked the Volvo XC90:
Until the new XC90 went on sale, Volvo was floating along aimlessly. On paper, the company competed with premium brands like BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, and Lexus, but in reality, its products were seriously outclassed. The redesigned XC90 crossover changed all that, and set the stage for future Volvos (the S90 and V90 most immediately) to adequately challenge their segment competitors.
From first glance, the XC90 demands attention. Its flowing body panels, sharp LED headlights, and squared shoulders instantly validate its luxury credentials. Base on the Swedish automaker’s new Scalable Product Architecture (SPA), the XC90 feels far lighter than its respectably slim 4,400-pound figure would suggest. As you jockey the electrically assisted steering, the crossover contains its body motions majestically, never disturbing the plush ride quality for up to seven passengers.
Speaking of life inside the XC90, Volvo’s interior design is now at the top of its class. Porous wood grain, brushed metals, and some of the softest leather we’ve ever felt is massaged in a gorgeous layout. It’s so easy to coast along in comfort that you might forget the XC90 is available with 316hp from a supercharged and turbocharged four-cylinder engine or 400hp (and 472 lb-ft of torque) from a plug-in hybrid powertrain. Add to all this Volvo’s celebrated safety standards (due to industry-first technologies) and the XC90 is a knockout.
Our full 2016 Volvo XC90 first-drive review
The best subcompact crossover
Why should you buy this: Adventure-ready looks and performance.
Who’s it for? Those who like to maximize utility and time outside.
How much will it cost? $18,445
Why we picked the Jeep Renegade:
If I were to tell you that a Fiat is great off-road, you’d probably laugh, but if I said the same about a Jeep, you might just say, “duh.” Therefore, what should we make of the Fiat 500L-based Jeep Renegade? With all-wheel drive instead of four-wheel drive, a cutesy design, and an economy car price tag, one could mistake this Jeep for a re-badged poser. Fortunately, however, the Renegade has what it takes to tackle the trails.
It’s possible to get a front-wheel drive-only Renegade, but the real fun starts with Jeep’s Selec-Terrain traction control and AWD system with a Power Transfer Unit. Unlike permanent AWD systems, the rear axle can be detached for better fuel economy. Even AWD models achieve up to 31 mpg on the highway. For serious off-roading, the Trailhawk edition adds reduction gears on the front and rear axles, skid plates, a 20:1 crawl ratio, and 8.7 inches of ground clearance.
Power is provided by either a turbocharged 1.4-liter four-cylinder, mated to a six-speed manual or nine-speed automatic, or a 2.4-liter turbo four-cylinder connected exclusively to the auto-box. While the Renegade can’t be called quick, its got enough grunt for moderate trails and acceptable passing power around town. Ride quality is quite good for a subcompact, and shifts via the manual gearbox are smooth.
Inside, the Renegade has ample passenger space (headroom, legroom, and shoulder width), and even the trunk has generous cargo capacity. Cabin material quality is excellent, and it’s easy to spot Jeep’s attention to detail. The Renegade is more than just the most rugged in its subcompact class; it’s the best product, period.
Our full 2015 Jeep Renegade Sport review
Porsche Macan Turbo
The best performance crossover
Why should you buy this: It’s literally the Porsche of small crossovers.
Who’s it for? Those who like to maximize utility but still have fun.
How much will it cost? $77,200+
Why we picked the Porsche Macan Turbo:
It may not be a 911, but the smaller of Porsche’s two crossovers is among the sportiest vehicles of its type. Like the larger Cayenne, the Macan tries hard to live up to the Porsche name. But more compact proportions make the Macan a much more probable canyon carver.
The Macan Turbo is the top-of-the-line version, and it offers performance to rival some sports cars. Its 3.6-liter, twin-turbocharged V6 produces 400 hp and 406 lb-ft. Porsche says that will get the Macan Turbo from 0 to 60 mph in 4.4 seconds with the available Sport Chrono Package, and on to a top speed of 164 mph. An optional Performance Package boosts output to 440 hp and 442 lb-ft, cutting the 0 to 60 mph time by 0.2 seconds, and increasing top speed by 5 mph.
Getting the most out of the Macan Turbo admittedly requires selecting a long list of options, including the Sport Chrono and Performance Packages, as well as the active suspension and torque-vectoring system. With all of that hardware, it can hang with Porsche’s more traditional sports cars. But even without it, the Macan Turbo is still a competent small crossover with a sporty character.
MINI Countryman S E ALL4
The most fuel-efficient crossover
Why should you buy this: It’s more car than crossover.
Who’s it for: Urbanites in need of a crossover.
How much will it cost: $36,900.00
Why we picked the MINI Countryman S E ALL4:
With its tiny footprint, low ride height, and lack off off-road pretensions, the Countryman is more of an enlarged MINI Cooper than a proper crossover, but that’s a good thing. It means you don’t have to sacrifice handling or fuel economy, especially if you opt for the Countryman S E ALL4 plug-in hybrid version.
That mess of letters and numbers means you get a 1.5-liter turbocharged three-cylinder engine, which powers the front wheels, and an electric motor that powers the rear wheels. Together, the two power sources provide 221 hp and 284 lb-ft of torque through all four wheels. MINI claims a respectable zero to 60 mph time of 6.7 seconds, and the plug-in hybrid Countryman will get 65 MPGe (miles per gallon equivalent) combined on electricity or 27 mpg combined on gasoline. An electric-only range of 12 miles is adequate but not world beating.
On the road, the Countryman S E ALL4 is both frugal and fun. The instant torque from its electric motor combines with the Countryman’s compact proportions to make for a lively driving experience. The Countryman is also easier to get in and out of than many other small crossovers, but easier to park than more traditional, larger models. The MINI’s retro styling also helps it stand out in a crowded parking lot.
Our full 2018 Countryman S E ALL4 review
How we test
The Digital Trends automotive team scrutinizes vehicles on the road through a comprehensive testing process. We examine the qualities of the exterior and interior and judge them based on our expertise and experience in the context of the vehicle’s category and price range. Entertainment technology is thoroughly tested, as well as most safety features that can be tested in controlled environments.
Test drivers spend extensive time behind the wheel of the vehicles, conducting real-world testing, driving them on highways, back roads, as well as off-road and race tracks when applicable.
Automakers tend to use the terms “crossover” and “SUV” interchangeably, but that isn’t really accurate. It’s mostly the fault of marketing departments: brands choose to describe their vehicles based on public sentiment more than accurate descriptions.
In this case, calling any of these vehicles we’ve listed “SUVs” would be incorrect. Here’s why: crossovers start with a car’s “unibody” architecture, which simply means the body of the car and its frame, or “foundation,” are a single piece. SUVs use a “body on frame” make-up that links two independent pieces together. This is really the only distinction between the two cars, but the side effects of unibody compared to body-on-frame are significant. A unibody is lighter, which leads to better fuel efficiency, agility, and a softer ride. Meanwhile, a heavier “body on frame” design is far more durable both in terms of rust and when driven on high-impact terrain.
Now that you know the basic differences you just need to decide how you’ll use your vehicle. Planning to do a lot of off-roading or towing? You’re looking for an SUV. Need something efficient, comfortable, and more affordable? A crossover is the right choice. With that covered, if you’ve made it to the bottom of this article and now know you need an SUV, we’d suggest reviewing our top SUV picks.